Ever notice two of Andy's girlfriends lived in the same Mayberry house?

It's also the location where Andy first falls for Ellie!

The love of Andy Taylor's life turned out to be Helen Crump, the school teacher he eventually wed. Most fans recall that their courtship began with a rocky start in the third season episode "Andy Discovers America," after Andy accidentally gets Opie and his friends to rebel against Helen in class.

Once everything smooths over in the end, the Mayberry sheriff walks the school teacher home, and there in front of her house marks the beginning of a cherished TV love story.

But have you ever really looked beyond the sentiment of the scene to note the house where Helen lives? Because it's a house in which Andy has found love once or twice before!

It turns out that not only was Mayberry a fictitious small town, but the lot where The Andy Griffith Show was filmed also had a limited number of houses for Mayberry residents to occupy. That meant some Mayberry residents had to share, and the hope was that the magic of television would help distract audiences from detecting all these familiar house exteriors.

But after watching again and again, it makes it easier to spot the similarities, and it just so happens that not only did Helen Crump live in the little house with the white picket fence marked "323," but so did Andy's girlfriend from earlier in the same season, Peggy McMillan (played by Joanna Moore).

Peggy was a nurse who Andy started to date in the third season episode "Andy's Rich Girlfriend." The episode kicked off with a hilarious double date between Andy and Peggy and Barney and Thelma Lou.

After a fun time at the lake, Andy walked Peggy up to her house, their arms around each other, and the steps they trotted up at the end of their date are the exact same ones on which Andy and Helen stand when their love first sparked. What a coincidence!

But wait, there's more.

At the very beginning of The Andy Griffith Show, Andy's love interest is Ellie Walker, a young pharmacist sweetheart. Although Ellie did not live in the same house as Helen and Peggy, it's a location where she and Andy spark their relationship.

In "Ellie Comes to Town," Emma Brand comes into Walker's Pharmacy on Ellie's first day. Ellie won't give her the medication she requests because Emma has no prescription. Andy protests Ellie's strictness, and as Emma feigns sickness denied her pills, the sheriff sets the town against Ellie, pressuring her to finally go to Emma's house to deliver the pills and bring her some soup, too.

When Ellie arrives at Emma's house, Andy's already there and he witnesses the pharmacist seeming to cave to the town's demands. Leaving the care package for Emma, Ellie exits, and Andy chases after her.

Pay attention when they meet on the lawn, and you'll notice Emma Brand lives in the same house where Peg and Helen eventually live. 

On Emma's front lawn, Andy asks Ellie what made her deliver the medicine, and she shatters his expectations by explaining that Emma's pills are just placebos and that her sickness is in her mind.

When Andy asks why Ellie didn't just give Emma the "sugar pills" in the first place then, she explains her dedication to following the rules, something that visibly impresses Andy, who expected to get Ellie to come around to his way of thinking, only to suddenly be vibing more with how she set her own mind.

The budding romance is only hinted at, as the scene ends in comedy, with Ellie talking Andy out of ticketing a car parked blocking a fire hydrant — only to then get into that same car and drive away.

But for any fan of this early Andy Taylor romance, this is where you could say it all began, in front of the very same house where Andy would find love again in the third season and eventually meet the woman he married. 

Watch The Andy Griffith Show on MeTV!

Weeknights at 7 PM & 7:30 PM

*available in most MeTV markets
Save with
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Close

7 Comments

Post a comment
Carolynfmr 2 days ago
I always like Peggy. I thought she and Andy made a good couple.
JanMMitchell 1 month ago
I think Andy should have married Elly Walker.
Rick 1 month ago
Emma ran a boarding house, duh. Maybe she and Mrs. Mendelbright were related.
Jay 1 month ago
Another one of Andy's girlfriend lived in this house as well. Mary in episode Threes a crowd. Some others lived there such as Mrs Elenora Poultice, Ethel the little girl with a stye, Charlie Varney, who bought Otis car. And Nellie. The house next door was Mrs Mendlebrights boarding house in which Barney lived. Ellie lived in it in episode Irresistible Andy. And Floyd lived in it in episode Divorce mountain style.
Frpaulhall 1 month ago
It was a small set. So they used the same house twice. They probably didn't think the people would catch on. Haha
denny Frpaulhall 22 days ago
I believe it was filmed right outside the studio lot. Not 100% sure, but I know Thelma Lou's house was like 3 doors down from studio entrance. There is a youtube video about it.
AnnaRentzVandenhazel 1 month ago
There's a simple explanation that could happen even in real life. These ladies weren't on the show at the same time, so obviously when one moved away, another moved into the house she vacated. :)
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?