Early reviews of Fantasy Island were no dream come true

Critics balked at the series, while the public flocked to it.

Early reviews of Fantasy Island were no dream come true
Sony Pictures Television

Though he was a performer all his life, there were very few things that Ricardo Montalbán valued more than security.

The life of a performer can be sudden and unexpected, and when Montalbán was offered the opportunity to star in a television program like Fantasy Island, he jumped at the opportunity.

“Actors are the most insecure people in the world,” wrote Montalbán in his memoir, Reflections: A Life in Two Worlds. “For thirty-five years, I have had a roller-coaster career, with the down periods outweighing those on top. Hence, I saw in Fantasy Island the chance for a wonderful ribbon to tie onto my career as a working actor.”

Fantasy Island

Watch Fantasy Island on MeTV!

Next Episode: Nov. 1 at 4PM

*available in most MeTV markets

However, the early days of the series were certainly rougher than expected, to put it lightly. “During all this time, I did not dare place too much hope that Fantasy Island would succeed,” wrote Montalbán. “The critics helped to curb my expectations. Their reviews were not just bad; they were abysmal.”

Luckily, the series wasn’t at the mercy of critics; In order to succeed, Fantasy Island needed the approval of the public, and audiences were more than happy to provide it.

“Thank heaven I was in a medium in which the public decided whether or not they liked a show,” wrote Montalbán. “They liked Fantasy Island. The series had been on the air only a few times when suddenly I was recognized everywhere I went, by all age groups.”