Boris Karloff used to receive angry letters from mothers claiming he'd given their children nightmares

For Karloff, fame came at a steep price.

Everett Collection

If you're a creative person who likes to share your work with others, one of the hard truths you'll have to face is that not everyone will love what you do. Sure, some critics are unnecessarily harsher than others, but it takes tough skin to be an artist. When you put your art into the world, you must understand that sometimes, it's enough for you to love it, instead of the rest of the population.

As the star of films like Frankenstein and The Mummy, Boris Karloff proved himself unmatched in the horror genre. However, one group of people who were none too pleased about the success was a group of mothers whose children had been frightened by Karloff's films.

In an interview with The Kansas City Star, Karloff revealed that he often received angry letters from these mothers, whose criticism wasn't easy to simply brush off.

"I needed success," he said. "I needed it darned badly. My wife and I had pretty tough sledding before it finally came...when mothers began writing me notes accusing me of giving their children nightmares, I wondered if it was all worth it."

It was an issue that plagued Karloff for longer than you'd think. "Of course, I tell myself that one of the oldest pastimes of children is to scare themselves," he said. "I've heard little girls talk themselves into believing the bogeyman is around the corner and apparently enjoy it. I know that adults love horror stories, that Poe is an international best-selling classic, and that magazines specializing in the weird can depend on monthly circulation. I tell myself I satisfy a normal instinct in people...But I guess a lot of that is a subconscious effort to convince myself."

But while mothers weren't too pleased with Karloff, that was nothing compared to the amount of love and appreciation that his fans had for him.

Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Close

14 Comments

musicman37 19 days ago
I saw "Frankenstein" for the first time at the tender age of 6. I had seen the picture of the Monster in an encyclopedia, and when I saw it was on TV in the afternoon (when no one else was at home but my Mom and my baby sister), I told Mom I wanted to watch it. She said OK, but she had to be there with me. She put my baby sister down for her nap, and we sat down to watch the movie. This was in 1965, and I identified SO MUCH with the Monster, that I wasn't scared at all, and my Mom wanted to know why. I told her I thought the villain, if there was one, was the Doctor, because the Monster didn't ask to be brought to life, much less with a criminal brain (that was Fritz' fault). I guess she thought I was quite insightful for a 6-year old. She never stopped me from watching what I wanted to watch again (until "The Exorcist" came out, which I didn't understand, because I had read the book and she knew it).
Avie 19 days ago
The solution was quite simple, moms: DON'T take your kids to see Karloff's movie or, if they were old enough to go on their own, bribe them to see anything EXCEPT his movies (which, kids being kids, all but guaranteed that they'd see the Karloffs and pocket the difference, but, well, you tried).
oneofthesedays1 19 days ago
11/2/2024..

I watched every movie on the "Creature Feature" movies on Saturday nights as a kid in the late 60s and later, and particularly loved the Universal Monsters the most.
My mother knew it was just part of growing up and back then, there really was not a lot of gore like today's horror movies. I think I might side with mothers today on some of the modern movies.
db13 19 days ago
From the time I can remember I watched them all Karloff.Lugosi,Chaney jr and sr.....all the greats and nightmares were plentiful ...and loved them all...thanks "Chilly Billy"
jvf 19 days ago
Simple solution: don't let your children watch scary movies. Problem solved.
AgingDisgracefully 21 days ago
Hoping BoKar responded each time with an It's-Only-a-Movie Form Letter.
Shaming and guilt-flinging are silly.
What's with the modern abbrev of Mr. Karloff's name? Respect, please.
Harmless would-be comedy. Didn't expect a vigilant respect-monitor on apology-demand duty.
Because that also would be silly.
Harrumph on, muman.
Arti44 22 days ago
Boris Karloff was an absolute genius when it came to projecting horror on the big screen. He was also quite a gentleman. My Great Aunt knew him personally. He was her customer in Wanamakers department store “which is now Macy’s “ in New York City. He actually provided her with tickets to the premiere of Frankenstein. He was a true star in every sense of the word.
McGillahooala 23 days ago
Karloff’s mummy is one of the most frightening movies ever.
Runeshaper 23 days ago
Karloff was AWESOME! The real question is, "Why were mothers letting their children watch these types of movies?" To me, the parents are responsible.
teire 23 days ago
My mom used to show a short version of The Mummy with Boris Karloff on the shade in our picture window as a Halloween decoration. No sound, just subtitles which of course displayed in reverse to trick or treaters outside. Kids would sit on the lawn to watch it (it was around 20-25 minutes long). One year a group of pre-teens knocked on our door after viewing and gave my mother candy as a thank you.
MrsPhilHarris teire 23 days ago
Nice story! 🎃👻
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?