Carl Reiner said that this aspect of The Dick Van Dyke Show dated the series

Reiner said this aspect of the show was "sort of embarrassing."

Genesis International

One of the best parts about The Dick Van Dyke Show is its timeless nature. The show doesn't engage in topical references too frequently, and although it was shot in black-and-white, the Petrie family can't help but remind us of our own at times. When we look at a show like The Dick Van Dyke Show, we see ourselves, no matter how old we are, or how old the series is, when we're watching.

However, series creator Carl Reiner once revealed that there were elements of the series that he felt dated the show. In an interview with the Garnett News Service, Reiner once said that he regretted the way that the character of Sally Rogers seemed to choose her career at the expense of her own love life.

While Sally's misadventures were entertainment to the audience, Reiner believed that, in retrospect, it wasn't really fair to depict working women in that light. "That's sort of embarrassing today," Reiner said. "It was based on my life. That's the way women were then."

In another interview with The News Journal, Reiner said that, similarly, he felt that a mention of Laura Petrie's abandonment of her career as a dancer to become a mother hadn't aged very well.

"Those I am embarrassed about," he said. "I wouldn't write them today. Mary Tyler Moore as Laura Petrie says she wanted to be dancing on [The Alan Brady Show] and then says, 'Oh, no. I just wanted to try it once. I am really happy being a housewife.' You know you can't do that now."

Reiner also felt that, while the Petrie family was content to live on Rob's salary as a writer alone, it wasn't an accurate representation of the American household. "You need two salaries to exist," Reiner said.

Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Close

23 Comments

DeborahRoberts 4 months ago
My mom worked outside the home then, but most of her friends stayed at home. I think Sally and Laura portrayed different options. The only offensive thing was the poor husband-hunting Sal routine. That got old.
deltadart 4 months ago
Despite his talent, he's an idiot!
FloridaTopCat deltadart 3 months ago
No, the real idiot would be his son, Rob Reiner!
deltadart FloridaTopCat 3 months ago
Rob Reiner is an idiot Meathead to be precise!
scp 4 months ago
My mother was a stay at home mother in the 1960s and I'm pretty sure my father wasn't making as much as the head writer on a hit TV show would have been making, but they did okay with two kids (and the three (including myself) that came along after).
Amalthea 4 months ago
"Mary Tyler Moore as Laura Petrie says she wanted to be dancing on [The Alan Brady Show] and then says, 'Oh, no. I just wanted to try it once. I am really happy being a housewife.' You know you can't do that now."

Why is it sad that she actually WANTED to be a SAHM, and just wanted to try the dancing once? It's bad enough that women are made to feel "less" if they're NOT out in the "working world"; If she wanted to stay home and could, that shouldn't be a negative thing.
Sooner 4 months ago
That's sad he was embarrassed about that.
AnnieM 4 months ago
Granted, the show is still as funny today, but I would have said the set for the Petrie house dates it perfectly to the time period. If I could have had any old B&W show have been done in color instead, it would have been The Dick Van Dyke Show, as I'm nuts about the decor of that era. 😊
drrmb 4 months ago
I'm not sure any show can be completely ageless, but the Dick Van Dyke comes close. I agree the episodes with the "twizzle" and the episode with Chad and Jeremy date the show, and I would add the episode where Rob looks for old radio stars helps date the show. But when I catch an episode, I find I am still laughing. Reiner's best decision was to ditch the original pilot in which he was the star. That was a save for the ages.
MadMadMadWorld drrmb 3 months ago
Carl Reiner did not make that decision to un-cast himself in the role of Rob. It was Sheldon Leonard who wanted a better actor for the character. The choice was between Dick Van Dyke, and Johnny Carson! Can you imagine Carson as Rob Petrie! Dick won because of his magnificent playing of Albert Peterson in the "Bye Bye Birdie" Broadway hit from 1960-61. Dick Gautier played the rock 'n' roll star 'Conrad Birdie' drafted into the Army. Gautier later famously played Hymie the Robot in "Get Smart."
Jon 4 months ago
My least favorite episodes of the series are those that showed Sally in yet another ill-fated romance with lots of maudlin music included. I did like the last "Sally in Love" episode though, "Dear Sally Rogers", because it was played for fun, not drama.
cperrynaples 4 months ago
The Laura issue was sorta addressed in the reunion special! It was revealed she was teaching dancing to young girls!
rickhoover1950 4 months ago
In my opinion the shows that I found rooted in the sixties were “The Twizzle” and “The Recoats Are Coming”. Those set the timeframe. Most of the episodes are more generic.
AgingDisgracefully 4 months ago
I thought he might have wanted to provide Herman Glimscher with a personality.
Remember Mrs. Glimscher, Herman’s mother?!?😅😂🤣
I looked her up. Elvia Allman. A familiar face with a name I just learned.
A sitcom go-to when you need...Severe.
https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0021519/?ref_=tt_cl_t_7
Yeah, I didn’t realize she was the “Speed it up a little” lady on I Love Lucy!!!!😅🤣😂
Wiseguy70005 cinamac 4 months ago
Coincidentally she also tried to get Lucy a job on The Lucy Show and was also one of the actresses to play Oscar's mother on The Odd Couple. I've known who she was by name from her many TV appearances over the years including the main actress to play Selma Plout on Petticoat Junction. She also played other parts in earlier episodes.
MadMadMadWorld cinamac 3 months ago
White Fang!
[a sly Soupy Sales puppet reference!] Loved that gag line!
Runeshaper 4 months ago
I get what Reiner is stating, but when the show was aired, the world was a different place.

On the other hand, the concept of "You need two salaries to exist," is relevant today.
Sway Runeshaper 4 months ago
I was thinking the same thing
JeanInTN Runeshaper 4 months ago
Most people lived on one income back in the 60s.
MadMadMadWorld JeanInTN 3 months ago
And that was because their were (90%) silver coins [dimes/quarters/halves], and the 'dollar' was strictly tied to gold at $35/oz. until no more tie to gold after Aug. 15, 1971. It's now over $2,440/oz, showing how much the paper "dollar" has been inflated to almost nothing by the Federal Reserve central bank machinery from Aug. 1971!
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?