The writer of the Perry Mason books began to see Raymond Burr as the ''real'' Perry Mason

"He puts on the character like a cloak."

CBS Television Distribution

Every now and again, the stars in Hollywood align, and we get a perfect casting choice. Such was the case all those decades ago when Raymond Burr auditioned for Perry Mason. Burr had to strong-arm his way into auditioning for the series protagonist and had to prove to producers that he'd be a worthy Perry Mason. It actually took praise from Erle Stanley Gardner, who took one look at Burr and exclaimed "That's our Perry Mason," to really seal the deal and win Burr the role.

However, once Burr was cast as Mason, no one ever questioned his ability to play the character ever again.

According to an interview with the Copley News Service, Gardner confirmed that his initial decision was the right one and that Burr himself was the best person to play Perry Mason. So much so did Burr resemble the character, that Gardner had begun thinking of Burr as a stand-in for a character he created.

"It's getting so I think of Raymond Burr as the real Perry Mason," Gardner said. "Ray thinks of himself as Perry Mason. He puts on the character like a cloak."

In Gardner's original book series, the appearance of Perry Mason was more mysterious than the show let on, with the author preferring instead to let his readers do the casting of characters. For Gardner, the less descriptive, the better.

"Perry, for example, I described only as being tall and wavy-haired," he said. "Why? I figured some people like brunettes, some like men with blonde hair. Let 'em all visualize their own Perry."

But when the time came to develop the book series into television, Gardner ran into some familiar issues. "It did become a problem in casting the TV show," he said. "Everyone had their own idea of how Perry should look. Could have been different, though."

Luckily, while interpretation is absolutely up to the viewer, Gardner knew his character better than anyone else.

"At first, Ray Burr read for the part of Ham Burger and Talman tried out to play Perry Mason," he said. "This didn't quite seem right. When we straightened them out, we were on our way."

Watch Perry Mason on MeTV!

Weekdays at 9 AM
Weeknights at 11:30 PM

*available in most MeTV markets
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Close

19 Comments

IdaKnow56 5 months ago
Why did Erle Stanley Gardner become so disenchanted with Raymond Burr in later years that he referred to him as having "cow eyes"? I always thought Burr had soulful dark eyes, very expressive when expressing sympathy for a person's misfortune or mistreatment, hard and angry when confronting a guilty person in court or disagreeing with Hamilton Burger or that smarmy cop who supported him. Did Burr do something that Gardner didn't approve of? Or was he just tired of looking at him?
DS62 IdaKnow56 5 months ago
Good question! I totally agree with you in that Raymond Burr had such expressively soulful eyes, he didn’t need to say anything and you could see the empathy or disbelief whatever the moment called for. Maybe “Cow eyes” was an affectionate term in Gardner’s mind, but it does sound disapproving. I wonder what Burr thought of it.
daalye 5 months ago
Me=tv is a celebration of TV shows of the past. I would like to tell everyone of a pop recording, released in 1978, that also celebrated the current shows of that era. It was called "Watching TV", and it was performed by an English group called Charlie, who sang "Watching TV, the American shows, watching TV, those superheroes..." Great nostalgia! Google it on Spotify.
Avie 5 months ago
Of course, Perry Mason's first screen incarnation was a four-film series, starting in 1934, with Warren William as Perry.
JamesB 5 months ago
It isn't likely a popular opinion, but I've always preferred Warren William's characterization of "Perry Mason" from the early serials. A 1930s star who worked both "A" and "B" studio releases plus radio, Warren William starred in 4 of the 6 Perry Mason "B movies" made from 1934-36 by Warner Brothers. This is back when Erle Stanley Gardner had just begun writing his Perry Mason books and the character was new. These were very popular and have held up better than most of the "A" list melodramas of that era.
daalye JamesB 5 months ago
Erle Stanley Gardners first Perry Mason novel was published in 1926. I had a paperback copy. As far as the movies you mention, it's like comparing apples to oranges. There's a lot of difference between creating a few movies in two years and making 26 tv shows a year, week after week, for 11 years. A movie actor, as any does, has time to study for the role, perfect it. Raymond Burr didn't have that kind of time.
DS62 daalye 5 months ago
But he sure aced it!
Runeshaper 5 months ago
I agree, Burr was the best person to play Perry Mason (-:
Scott76112 5 months ago
Burr's voice was a key part of the show's success. He didn't just look the part, he sounded smart, wise, and authoritative.

It's a tribute to Burr's portrayal, and the series itself, that it's on *twice* a day, six decades after it was created.

George58 5 months ago
I'm glad Raymond Burr didn't get the Hamilton Burger role & William Talman get the Perry Mason role. Raymond Burr is just "perfect" as Perry Mason. And, I can't see if Talman got the Perry Mason role how he would click with William Hopper (Paul Drake).
JHP 5 months ago
we need another Raymond Burr but in this cesspool of shows he/she/it would rather be a school bus driver
daalye JHP 5 months ago
Are you referring to the current shows on TV that are supposed to pass as entertainment? That's why me-tv was formulated. Perhaps those addicted to today's "cesspool" of shows will tune in to me-tv and see when TV had quality programming.
JHP daalye 5 months ago
exactly:)
cperrynaples 5 months ago
Gardner's memory was a little off! It was William Hopper NOT William Talman who auditioned to be Perry! It is TRUE that Burr was ALMOST Burger!
cinamac 5 months ago
I t didn’t hurt that Raymond Burr was dashing, debonair and devilishly handsome!!!😍
FLETCH 5 months ago
Raymond Burr is so amazing as Perry Mason that they truly seem like one person.
I've always thought, either Raymond Burr is a great actor or he's just being himself. The one episode where the Mason look alike sailor appears (played by Burr) was a little jarring the first time I saw it. It made me realize, yeah, maybe Raymond Burr is acting as Perry Mason after all 🤔
cinamac FLETCH 5 months ago
Actually, Raymond Burr always said that his personality more resembled Robert Ironside than that of Perry Mason!
JHP FLETCH 5 months ago
and he was super on old time radio - look up Fort Laramie
daalye FLETCH 5 months ago
That was one great episode.
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?