Christmas movie showdown: Which one's better?

It's a Santa smackdown!

 20th Century Studios/Warner Bros./New Line Cinema/Paramount Pictures/Universal Pictures

It's a tinsel-time tournament! Who will be crowned the king of Christmas cinema?

We've paired up some holiday classics, and we want you to choose the ones you prefer. But, here's the thing... We don't want just your pick. We want to know why as well down in the comments section! So please, share your yuletide opinion with your MeTV neighbors!

  1. Which Christmas movie is better?
  2. Which Christmas movie is better?
  3. Which Christmas movie is better?
  4. Which Christmas movie is better?
  5. Which Christmas movie is better?
  6. Which Christmas movie is better?
  7. Which Christmas movie is better?
  8. Which Christmas movie is better?
  9. Which Christmas movie is better?
  10. Which Christmas movie is better?

Christmas movie showdown: Which one's better?

Your Result...

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Pellentesque nec ante ipsum. Mauris viverra, urna et porta sagittis, lorem diam dapibus diam, et lacinia libero quam id risus.
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Close

66 Comments

sagafrat69 11 hours ago
80% similar. Pretty ok I guess. What about "Die Hard" on this list of great Christmas movies? One of the all- time best. I always get the Christmas spirit when the bad guys get it but good. I have a machine gun. HO HO HO!
StrayCat 12 hours ago
I refuse to believe people liked this 1954 A Christmas Carol over The Bishop's Wife. This version of A Christmas Carol was a made for TV hour long version. Now, if the comparison were between The Bishop's Wife and the 1951 version of A Christmas Carol starring Alistair Sim, I could understand that.
Wendy57 21 hours ago
80% similar
My favorites are -
A Charlie Brown Christmas
A Christmas Story
Planes, Trains, and Automobiles
JHP 22 hours ago
60%-ter sorry don't really care for any of these (same ol' same ol') and some weren't even movies (my 2 cents opinion)

my fav holiday movie is Trains Planes and Automobiles
Wendy57 JHP 19 hours ago
Planes, Trains, and Automobiles is such a fabulous film.

John Candy was great !

The action scenes too.
One time, I had to divert to JFK, and needed to share a cab to get back to where my car was at the Newark, NJ airport. Four people, all strangers, without a lot of money. We shared our cab. Our taxi got caught in traffic
“ close “ to the exit for the Newark airport. Naturally the taxi meter kept running. We compared our funds and voted to pay the driver and get out with our luggage on the side of a snowy slushy freeway and walk up to the exit and over to the airport. We did it, and it reminds me
of this movie.
Merry Christmas 🎄
JHP Wendy57 19 hours ago
merry Christmas back at cha' and that real life scene is scary:)
sagafrat69 Wendy57 11 hours ago
Great story. Thanks for sharing that.
tinkparker 22 hours ago
Frosty is my favorite Christmas cartoon
jimmyvici 24 hours ago
Die Hard is my favorite Christmas movie. McClain vs. Gruber, Nakatomi Plaza…yippie Kay-yay!
tootsieg 1 day ago
90%. So many good Christmas movies. Was difficult to choose.
Lillyrose 1 day ago
My favorite Christmas movie (and book) of all time is Debbie Macomber's "Call Me Mrs. Miracle." Such a cute story! Lovely. Very sweet. It's a TV movie. It's on GAC Family.
Lillyrose 1 day ago
60% similar. I love "Miracle on 34th Street". I saw both movies. The 1947 movie is the best. The 1994 version is okay, but just not nearly as good as the first movie.
"Elf" is hilarious! And "A Charlie Brown Christmas" is adorable, sweet and wholesome.
They forgot "The Sound of Music." Isn't that billed as a Christmas movie?
Big3Fan 1 day ago
4️⃣0️⃣ Haven't seen a lot of these.
MrsPhilHarris 1 day ago
60% similar. Some were hard to pick. Not a fan of either Nightmare Before Christmas (it’s okay) nor Polar Express which I find kind of creepy. A few were eeny, meeny, many, moe.
Miny not many. I wish we could edit comments.
JHP MrsPhilHarris 21 hours ago
Hint hint :) You can ; What you do is with your mouse (left button hold down) swipe over your comment (it turns a brownish color). Then copy the selection and then delete your org comment and then paste your org comment and edit as needed
top_cat_james_1 1 day ago
Only MeTV Staff would classify TV specials as "movies".
MikefromJersey 1 day ago
70% similar.
My mom's classmate at Hammond High, Jean Shepherd, wrote A Christmas Story.
Flick and they guys are real people, they are in her yearbook which Shep signed.
"Flick" for Flickinger. I talked to Shep twice, he appears in the movie, the bearded man
who tells the kid not to cut in line to see Santa.
Jacki MikefromJersey 1 day ago
Wow, Mike that is so amazing! That must have been so cool to talk with him. And I do remember that part in the movie. I love that movie.🎅
MikefromJersey Jacki 1 day ago
Shep was first a humorist on WOR radio, from the 50's to early 80's, every night he'd
tell stories like the several he melded together to make the Christmas Story.
He wrote many books as well of short stories. Lots of material there for sequels to
A Christmas Story, I am surprised some smart producer hasn't jumped at the chance.
Great story! He was a great story teller. I have listened to him in otr. I believe he had a show for years. I read his book too. It was interesting that stories were mashed together for the movie.
MrsPhilHarris Jacki 1 day ago
I love it too!
Mrs. Harris,
I'm not surprised you heard him up in the Great White North, WOR is one of the most powerful stations in North America. At 10:15 at night Shep's program was heard in many places far beyond
its normal signal range as many stations signed off earlier in the evening.
Plus local stations in far off areas also ran it.
He did a TV series for New Jersey Public television. He considered the state "America writ
small", with its varied geography and many different types of people with traditional
heartland festivals like the Flemington Fair which he immortalized in a much lauded
Playboy article.
On more than one occasion he talked about my hometown of Westfield deeming it the
beginning of "John Cheever Country" that ran up to Conn.
He enjoyed doing his talks at Jersey venues, I saw him at Princeton, Union College,
he came to the small auditorium every year at Summit High because he loved the
town. He did a whole show on Route 22 and the Leaning Tower of Pizza as emblematic
of what he lovingly called "slob culture".
Magleedia 1 day ago
70 % similar. Some of these choices are just too hard to make - so many wonderful memories
bmoore4026 1 day ago
40% similar. Like hell is that uncanny valley monstrosity The Polar Express better than The Nightmare Before Christmas.
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?