20%. I chose "The Little Drummer Boy" by the Harry Simeone Chorale. But, I like *the original* 1958 recording of that song and *not* that remake from circa 1964.

What about "Snoopy's Christmas" by the Royal Guardsmen from 1967? I also liked that one. It was also my Mom's (may she rest in peace) all-time favorite Christmas song.

Jingle Bell Rock by Bobby Helms.

O Holy Night is a beautiful song

So 20% similar, my "go to" song would be, "Still, Still, Stiill".

what about the Ding dong song?
by George Harrison??
Original and good tune

happy christmas
war is over (if you want)
John and yoko
that is my favorite but not on your list

100% O' Holy Night 🌟

Can't go wrong with Mariah Carey, the "Queen of Chr

What about Good King What's-his-face?

I have a strong, sentimental attachment to #2 all-time The Christmas Song (Christmas Don't Be Late)" from 1958.
There was never a better year in U.S. history than that one, peace (no dumb, wasteful foreign wars), no riots, no impeachments, increasing prosperity (the dollar was a fixed weight of gold at $35/oz.). And the year had the greatest fads (Hula Hoop) and 3 novelty songs: the above, plus #1 all-time "Purple People Eater" (Sheb Wooley; then on Rawhide--along with a young Clint Eastwood), and the earlier Chipmunks' (related) hit, #4 all-time "Witch Doctor" (David Seville--> Ross Bagsdasarian, voice of D.S.), plus "Yakety Yak" by The Coasters, #16 all-time "Beep Beep" by The Playmates, plus other minor novelty tunes, as is #99 all-time "Delcious" by Jim Backus ["Thurston Howell III" on 'Gilligan's Island" 1964-67] and Friend! No doubt, 1958 was one of the greatest years in the 247 years (1776) of the U.S.! https://www.waybackattack.com/top100-noveltyhits.html

They didn't even have my choice for my favorite Christmas song.
"Father Christmas"
by Emerson, Lake & Palmer

Too many good ones, can't pick jist one

Surprised they didn't throw in "Grandma Got Run Over by a Reindeer" for a comedic offering. 🦌

I chose O Holy Night, also like Bing & David Bowie duet of Little Drummer Boy/Peace on Earth. 12 Pains of Christmas is fun.

Never get tired of All I Want Fir Christmas Is You!

Love O'Holy Night, It says it All.

Picked O' Holy Night and got 100% similar! I LOVE that song, but my actual favorites are O Come All Ye Faithful and O Come O Come Emmanuel and God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen. I love basically all those songs on the list! Christmas music is great!

This depends on who's singing the song. The remakes of almost all theses songs are just terrible, makes me cringe when I hear them.

I think I've provided my #1 more than once. Re-repeating...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yWcFiGKm-JU

You left out "Rocking around the Christmas Tree" by Brenda Lee

Left out two of the biggest ones, and my two favorites- Nat King Cole 'The Christmas Song' and Mel Torme 'Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas'.