At first, Amanda Blake hated Milburn Stone and he had no idea

They were one big happy family—almost.

The Everett Collection

Gunsmoke (1955) was known for having one of the most talented and tight-knit casts in the business. Their long 20-season run could only be made possible by a positive workplace, minimal drama and cohesive chemistry.

However, according to a 1963 interview with The Toronto Star, Amanda Blake revealed that the cast's close camaraderie didn't start strong. 

In the world of Hollywood, friendship among co-stars is a natural part of show business, but they can also be a tenuous thing. One stolen scene or part, upstaging, or a snubbed award can make two old buddies turn into the worst of enemies. 

In fact, Blake, who was known for her role as Kitty Russell, said she initally disliked her co-star Milburn Stone for exactly that reason.

"At first, I hated Milburn," Blake said. "He got third billing on the show, and I wanted it."

Dennis Weaver, who left Gunsmoke after nine seasons, held the second spot. This left Blake in fourth place, which isn't a prime place to be for any actor. Once Weaver left the series, Blake moved up to third billing, with Stone advancing to second.

"I had no idea she resented me at the time," Stone said. "All I knew was that she laughed at my jokes and that was good enough for me."

The two actors may have had their initial disagreements, but they did agree on one thing: their love for leading star James Arness. They considered him to be one of the best actors in the world, even beating out big move stars like John Wayne and Robert Redford. 

"He's the guy that makes the show a hit year after year," Stone said. 

"Amen," Blake added. "He goes through the script and changes the lines to give us more to do. How many stars do you find doing that?"

According to the interview, Stone said the Gunsmoke scripts were more like a guide map rather than a strict blueprint. After 20 years on-air, the cast had created close bonds and knew the characters so well they would invent their own storylines, dialogue and roles along the way.

Over time, Blake and Stone had a beautiful friendship that only grew stronger as the series progressed. Soon, after 20 seasons, a lot of money, and endless fame, the order of the billing didn't matter to Blake anymore.

Oh, and they had one more thing in common: their love for the series.

"I've been an actor all my life, and a show like Gunsmoke comes along only once," Stone said. 

"I feel the same way," Blake added. "We're almost like family now. We have parties on the set with the crew members whenever there's a special occasion. As far as I know, there is nothing like it in show business."

Watch Gunsmoke on MeTV!

Monday - Saturday at 1 PM & 1:30 PM

*available in most MeTV markets
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Close

9 Comments

cperrynaples 1 month ago
Actually, during the last years of the show,Stone & Blake were on top as Arness came last! The other stars came first before "and starring James Arness as Matt Dillon!" To be fair, Arness did less work by the end, and I remember MAD even goofing on that!
gig889 1 month ago
I have trouble believing this story because Milburn Stone was a well-established actor before Gunsmoke. Amanda Blake and James Arness had only done a few movies before Gunsmoke. Amanda Blake only got first billing in two films. She was dropped from MGM and only a bit player after that. She would not have seen herself as a bigger star than Milburn Stone, who was big when Gunsmoke started, with many roles to his credit. She may have felt she should get billing over Denes Weaver who was also an unknown at the time, but for the first few years, the Kitty part was not considered a main role. She felt they might replace her at any time. This story seems made up to me.
cperrynaples gig889 1 month ago
Who is Denes Weaver? Was that Dennis' sister...LOL! Can't blame Spellcheck for THAT one!
KJExpress 1 month ago
Nice photo of Stars 2, 3 and 4. 😊
deltadart 1 month ago
Please don't put that idiot Robert Redford in the same league with John Wayne!
McGillahooala deltadart 1 month ago
I second that.
SDWriter deltadart 1 month ago
Robert Redford is a gifted actor, director and producer. He has been a far more accomplished performer than Duke Wayne, who was basically a one-note actor. But your ignorant comment is about politics, not performing, right?
SDWriter 1 month ago
This comment has been removed.
SDWriter deltadart 1 month ago
Your comment is absurd on its face. Redford starred in and directed several classics. John Wayne made a few great films and a bunch of mediocre ones. Both were major stars, but Redford is an artist.
Politics aside, you’re deeply uninformed.
deltadart SDWriter 1 month ago
You are projecting again! Whatever medication you are taking it is not working for you.
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?