Jerry Mathers reveals the reason Leave It to Beaver ended early

The series could've continued!

NBC/Universal

All things, both good and bad, must eventually come to an end. That's one of the cruel truths of the world. No matter how much we love something, no matter how hard we want to hold onto it, at some point, it's time to say goodbye. That's the case for pets, stamp collections, treehouses, and even sitcoms. Our favorite shows all wrap it up and call it a day.

But one legendary show could have gone on longer, at least according to the people making it. Apparently, there was an effort to extend Leave It to Beaver for a few further seasons. And why not? The stuff that made the show special was still all right there. Wally and Beaver were still brothers, and Ward and June were still parents. The stories would've written themselves! Who knows the adventures Beaver could've gotten into in college and beyond?

Eventually, they rebooted the series with The New Leave It to Beaver, proving there was still meat on the narrative bone. The audience would've been there, too. So, why did the show end?

Watch Leave It to Beaver on MeTV!

Weekdays at 8 & 8:30 AM, Sundays at 1 & 1:30 PM

*available in most MeTV markets

A 1983 Buffalo News interview with the Beaver himself, Jerry Mathers, sheds light on the production issues that led to the show's premature demise. ABC, which aired Leave It to Beaver from 1958 onward, wanted to make a radical shift in '63. The network proposed moving the show to an hour-long format. More to our point, though, ABC wanted to begin filming the show in color.

"At the time," said Mathers, "we had two days of rehearsal and three days of filming, which gave us a lot of what made it so well-written."

That time and attention translated to the screen. Leave It to Beaver remains popular, in part, because of the care that the writers and producers gave each story. The actors then had the space they needed to hone each scene until it was family portrait perfect.

"Due to the technology of color [in 1963], we were going to have to eliminate the two days of rehearsal and film it in six straight days.

"The producers really felt that would jeopardize the quality of the show and they said, 'We've had a good show, we've been on for six seasons; why try to squeeze two more years out of it and sacrifice quality?'."

But think of what could've been! Beaver goes to prom! Wally gets a job at a bank, or whatever! And all of it could've been in vibrant color picture! 

What do you think? Were we robbed of two seasons of TV's greatest family sitcom? Or were we better off leaving the show where it ended? Let us know your opinion in the comments section below!

Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Close

30 Comments

seaeagle 6 days ago
Regarding Beaver in the later seasons - Wally always seemed mature for his age, polite but could still be resolute, especially with his errant friends as he got older. I think he portrayed the type that my generation's parents aspired to for their kids. But as Beaver grew up, he lost that innocence and became more entitled, was less mature compared to Wally at the same age, and had little consideration for others, particularly S6.E25 The Silent Treatment, which I didn't enjoy at all. Also, continuing the series, particularly in color, would seem to have been a very poor choice. For me it is all about nostalgia so I like that it is in B&W, but that may be because I never saw LITB when originally aired. Perry Mason tried one episode in color and tanked that idea, albeit that series was more a film noir experience.
whiskers65 29 days ago
I don't know that Jerry Mathers would have continued to be a draw for viewers. While he was a cute kid and endeared to audiences , ,he was not a cute teenager and his acting had gotten very wooden towards the end. A better idea would have been to spinoff a series around Wally and his college adventures with Ward, June and the Beaver occasionally appearing.
Brad 1 month ago
Leave it to Beaver in COLOR?!? Absolutely not! If you need an example of how this change affects things, just look at The Andy Griffith Show... MeTV won't even show the color episodes, and I've never heard anyone complain about that. I've seen a couple color episodes, and it's hard to believe it's even the same show. It feels like a modern-day knock off, or maybe even like an SNL skit. No, Leave it to Beaver definitely wouldn't have worked. And - the final episode was the perfect way to end the series, instead of dragging everything out with new characters being introduced and other beloved characters leaving. The whole show, from beginning to end, was done perfectly!
Lilac6Lambie 1 month ago
I think the series ended at a good time. I wish that Larry Mondello could have continued to be on the show. He and Beaver might have had more exciting adventures if he had stayed. I think Tony Dow turned into a good actor, very natural sounding during the last year of the show.
LalaLucy 1 month ago
Love this show but glad it ended when it did. Just right. Unlike some shows that went on and on and darn near ruined their legacy before all was said and done.
DeputyWarren 1 month ago
The show had run it's course after 6 seasons. The final season could've been called "Leave it to Wally" , as many episodes were about his adventures with Eddie & Lumpy; Beaver's plots suffered by the loss of Larry Mondello, who was so good, the producers once considered a spinoff. Gilbert was a weak replacement.
The "color" story just doesn't ring true. TV networks had few primetime shows in color in the 1963 Fall season, which is when a (theoretical) '7th season' of LITB would've aired. Even in the Following season (1965-66), ABC had only 6 1/2 hrs of color programming. Color wasn't mandated for most shows until Fall season 1966. That's when several shows were dropped because ratings didn't merit the cost of converting to color ("Patty Duke") or technical problems ("Munsters & Addams Family")
tootsieg 1 month ago
I thought the show ended at a good time. Wally and his friends were going to college and Beaver was going to high school. Time to move on and color would not be good for that show.
Uscmanrob 1 month ago
Two things... Beaver's antics were more cute and innocent in the earlier episodes. By the last season or two, he should have known better, and would have gotten harsher punishment (in real life). Going to color episodes would have likely gotten the same result as The Andy Griffith Show did after they went to color. Black and white episodes fit this series perfectly.
SrLerxst Uscmanrob 1 month ago
Exactly, And when Larry was replaced with that jerk Gilbert the show was even worse.
Bapa1 1 month ago
Well, if you follow the series, Wally, Eddie and Lumpy were all going away to college. So how would they have worked that into storylines. Still, Beaver buying a Beatles wig would have been funny.
MichaelPowers Bapa1 1 month ago
Well, they could have written an "A" story & "B" story like they did on M*A*S*H. Each week we have two different plots going on. We have the Cleaver's home story with Ward, June and the Beave; and then you also have Wally's college stories with Eddie and Lumpy. Two stories going on would easily fill an hour format had ABC gone in that direction. However, I'm not sure if the series should have continued as much as I enjoyed it. Perhaps it was their time to ride off into the sunset.
VivianHodnett 1 month ago
I really like the black and white episodes, I don't think going to color would have been a good idea. I agree with the decision.
MrsPhilHarris 1 month ago
I think it ended at the right time. I would not have liked the show to venture into anything like the British Invasion or sending kids to Viet Nam.
SrLerxst MrsPhilHarris 1 month ago
No not exactly. I do not recall Vietnam being mentioned in My Three Sons, Gomer Pyle, The Donna Reed Show etc. And even when the Beatles performed on the Ed Sullivan Show, family sitcoms pretending the British Invasion did not exist was just not going to happen.
MrsPhilHarris SrLerxst 1 month ago
Well I like the 50s - early 60s vibe of LITB and was glad it ended when it did. Beaver was quite goofy and awkward. Wally was much better at being a teenager. As for the British Invasion TDVD Show, Patty Duke and even Batman had British musicians. I found those episodes lame, but to each his own.
SrLerxst MrsPhilHarris 1 month ago
Well yeah pop culture references are usually considered lame by the next generation. Nothing unusual about that. Just like Gen Z troll love to make fun of Gen X me and the 1980s. However suppose you think the Monkees are lame and try to post that in a Monkees group and see what reaction you get, Or how about this. I was given free tickets to see James Darren in Laughlin, Nevada and during his show he showed almost the entire cartoon episode of his character of him in the Flintstones and NOBODY thought that was LAME! However yeah James Darren did sort of make fun of himself in the some the scenes of T.J. Hooker.
MrsPhilHarris SrLerxst 1 month ago
I love James Darren’s The Flintstones episode! In fact like any of the “celebrity “ episodes such as those with Ann-Margret, Perry Mason, etc. I’ve never seen T.J. Hooker and didn’t realize he was on the show. 🤔
teire 1 month ago
It is perfect as it was, existing in a very idealized window from 1957 to 1963, notably ending before November 1963. It spanned a very precise period in a family’s life, and in the stages of childhood to young adulthood. And because TV seasons were longer back then (and Leave It to Beaver ran a consistent 39 episodes a season), there was a lot packed into those six years.
justjeff 1 month ago
Let sleeping beavers build dams...😋
Coldnorth justjeff 1 month ago
DAM🤡🤡🤡
WordsmithWorks 1 month ago
They could have introduced Wally and Beaver's cousin Oliver. Or after Wally went away to Medfield College, Ward and June could have adopted a little boy named Ernie.
And Eddie could of done 3-5 years.
Ironically, Ernie first appeared on M3S the year after Beaver ended! And would you believe Tony Dow made a guest appearance that same season? You can see it on Catchy Comedy!
Wiseguy70005 BrittReid 1 month ago
Could have not could of.
I don’t like that M3S episode. They are all so mean to Tony Dow’s character. 🤨
albertme6197 1 month ago
I am with ABC on what should have been the future of Leave It To Beaver. Television of that time frame was going to color production, and I believe that the producers of Leave It To Beaver would have eventually been behind the times in a changing media culture.

I wanted to see Beaver grow-up and get a spine. I have long felt that he was too naïve. (A part of the legacy of the program that was encouraged by the producers, but hated by me). I wanted to see a new Beaver who would have put Larry Mondello in his place. I do believe that the mother of Beaver’s best friend should have been younger; and I did want to see his older sister. (who was unseen throughout the series) I would have liked to see Larry reflect on getting spanked by his younger mother on the newer episode of the series. (And he needed a spanking; and she talks gently to him before hugging a sobbing and contrite Larry afterwards; that would have been justice). I actually do believe that Beaver himself had unspoken fears about being spanked by his parents that could have been explored had the series been expanded. (Season 1 episode from ‘Beaver Gets Spelled' “His mother spanked him and I spanked him”) It would have been neat to see Beaver getting chewed out by Miss Landers after class to be heard by classmates in a nightmare.

I understand that on the last season, the producers were conservative around Beaver and girls. I wanted to see Beaver get a steady girlfriend. As per Olivia Rodrigo; I wanted to see Beaver get romantic revenge; especially on that Penny Woods (Sue Trent) who leaked Beaver’s secret football play in the last episode of season 3, and I especially wanted to see Beaver get revenge on that line-backer (Penny’s brother) who did that turnover on the Beaver. In fact, I would have loved to have seen a tense feud between beaver and Penny’s brother. Here’s a surprising romantic pairing; Judy Hensler (Jeri Weil) and Whitey Whitney. (Stanley Fafara)

An expanded series would have been perfect for the Beatles era and the British Invasion in pop music. While I do agree that civil rights and reform would have been ahead of the time; I do think that the show could have introduced black characters with some finesse. The show would have benefited from a talented soul singer with an integrated girl group. (Jerry Mathers was never a talented singer, and this was a void). How about a nervous black pitcher who has Beaver as a battery-mate on the baseball team. I think that Wally could have gotten a significant athletic scholarship at a local college; and build up the romantic rivalry between Mary Ellen Rogers (Pamela Baird) and Julie Foster. (Cheryl Holdridge). It would be interesting to see Beaver and Julie connecting and seeing Beaver get into a heated argument with Wally over it.

Finally, Leave It To Beaver could have continued had ABC abandoned its pursuit of hour long episodes; which it did not need; and this would have kept the rehearsal schedule in place.












Miss Landers didn’t come along until season 2. Miss Canfield was in “Beaver gets spelled”
Fun Fact: ABC also considered an hour and color for The Rifleman, but Chuck Conners said no! They did get Wagon Train to become 90 minutes in color, but the show ended in black and white! Yes, those episodes ran on Saturday westerns at one point! And there are color photos from Beaver's last season! One of them shows up on the Frndly menu!
Many series expanded around that time including Twilight Zone (for one season), Gunsmoke, Alfred Hitchcock, Robert Taylor's Detectives, etc. Half-hour dramas were going out of style. Only Jack Webb continued to produce half-hour dramas into the 1970s.
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?