Raymond Burr felt that the Perry Mason book series couldn't be properly adapted into a television series

"You couldn't and we didn't do one of Erle Stanley Gardner's great stories in one hour," said Burr.

CBS Television Distribution

Though the adaptation of a book to television can seem simple to the average audience member, it's easier said than done.

One of the more successful book-to-television adaptations was Perry Mason. The television series, which ran for nine seasons, was based on a series of novels written by acclaimed author Erle Stanley Gardner.

With great respect for the material, producers involved Gardner in the pre-production process of Perry Mason, with Gardner hand-picking actor Raymond Burr for the title role.

But years after the show aired, Burr confessed that the limited time slot that television provided meant that no matter how hard they tried, cast and crew alike could never do Gardner's work justice.

"You couldn't and we didn't do one of Erle Stanley Gardner's great stories in one hour," said Burr during an interview with the Spokesman-Review. "To squeeze into the time slot made it necessary to cut down on the number of clues. The audience never got background on the characters or on Perry Mason himself. You didn't know whether he'd been a test-tube baby or an immaculate conception."

After the series wrapped, Burr returned to the role for various Perry Mason films. These programs allowed for more time, which Burr believed was the secret ingredient to a proper adaptation. "Now, we're doing it right," said Burr. "I'm working with Fred Silverman and Dean Hargrove writes the best stories in the world."

Ultimately, Burr felt that he was indebted to Gardner, who had gifted him with the role of a lifetime. The actor was determined to return the favor to the best of his ability.

"When they came to me last winter with Perry Mason returns, I was delighted," said Burr. "I felt I owed it to Erle's memory and to his wife, Jean, a lovely lady, to do a two-hour Perry Mason movie the way it should be done. I'll keep on doing them as long as Silverman and Hargrove want to do them."

Watch Perry Mason on MeTV!

Weekdays at 9 AM
Weeknights at 11:30 PM

*available in most MeTV markets
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Close

6 Comments

MrsPhilHarris 1 month ago
I still like the 1 hour condensed Perry Mason tv show. I found the 2 hour movies lacking and they plodded along. I suppose in part because Perry was retired and Paul was dead. The office no longer existed and the mansions and swanky penthouses were gone. I think they ended up in Colorado.
CaptainDunsel 1 month ago
This is very true of many if not most book-to-film adaptations, and especially complex mysteries. You can see the same effect with series like "Ellery Queen" (1975) or "Nero Wolfe" (1981). Even when they did direct adaptations, they were so pared down that dear Nero seemed positively skinny! And with Ellery? His final exposition of the solution would have been longer than the full hour, forget about laying out the clues and false trails!
ncadams27 1 month ago
I’d rather have a novel condensed to a one-hour show than have one turned into a 10-episode miniseries.
CaptainDunsel ncadams27 1 month ago
Though I take your point, I'll give you just one counter-example. James Clavell's "Shogun".

That book is so dense that, when it was first done for television as a 10-hour television miniseries in 1980, they still had to cut a huge number of subplots and themes from the novel. Edited down to a (more or less) 2 1/2 hour length, as it was, it's less a movie than an extended long trailer.
ncadams27 CaptainDunsel 1 month ago
Yes but Shogun is 1,312 pages long. A typical Perry Mason book is about 200-250 pages long.
CaptainDunsel ncadams27 30 days ago
[image=https://weigel-comments.s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/GsHvA-1738160370-Python-FairCop.gif]
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?