The 10 most forgotten spin-offs of smash TV shows

None of them lasted more than 16 episodes.

Gunsmoke, Cheers, M*A*S*H and Happy Days are some of the longest-running primetime series in television history. When a show lasts for a decade, audiences clearly care. 

No wonder that networks then try to keep a good thing going with spin-offs. Happy Days spawned Laverne & Shirley, which went on to become the most-watched show on television in 1977. Cheers begat Frasier, which lasted just as long as its parent, 11 seasons.

But those juggernauts also gave us Blanksky's Beauties and The Tortellis. They can't all be winners.

The following 10 shows were all born from beloved classics — and they all flopped. Did you watch any of them?

1. Blansky's Beauties

Happy Days
13 episodes

Garry Marshall became somewhat obsessed with making a sitcom about Las Vegas showgirls. His first attempt was built as a spin-off of his smash hit Happy DaysLaverne & Shirley and Mork & Mindy, which premiered in the autumns of 1976 and 1978, respectively, were both wildly successful spin-offs of Happy Days. However, there was another spin-off between those two pop-culture sensations. On February 4, 1977, Happy Days aired its "Third Anniversary Show" episode. Nancy Walker guest-starred as Howard Cunningham's cousin Nancy Blansky, a Las Vegas showbiz professional who acted as a den mother to a gaggle of showgirls. This led to a full series titled Blanksy's Beauties, which began the following week on ABC. The cast of Beauties also included the young and lovely Lynda Goodfriend as "Sunshine," as well as 16-year-old Scott Baio, who played a precocious and tough 12-year-old named Anthony DeLuca. The show also had a link to Laverne & Shirley, as Eddie Mekka, the actor best known as Shirley's boyfriend Carmine Ragusa, portrayed the character Joey DeLuca, the Carmine's younger cousin

Image: The Everett Collection

2. Dirty Sally

Gunsmoke
13 episodes

Dirty Sally holds the distinction of being the only spin-off of Gunsmoke in the show's 20-year run. Perhaps they shouldn't have waited so long. This series began as the two-part finale of season 16, "Pike," in which a young gunslinger named Cyrus Pike (Dack Rambo) is nursed back to health by a toothless outcast named Sally. Sally, a sort of cross of Yosemite Sam and a crusty old witch, was played by the venerable Jeanette Nolan, who had once starred alongside Orson Welles as Lady Macbeth. Nolan had also guest-starred on Gunsmoke more than any other woman, so she deserved this headlining role. She earned an Emmy nomination for this role, but it was no match for Sanford and Son. CBS pulled the plug before the Emmys were handed out.

Image: The Everett Collection

3. Getting Together

The Partridge Family
14 episodes

Teen idol Bobby Sherman and Wes Stern (how was he not a cowboy?) played Bobby Conway and Lionel Poindexter, two songwriters looking for the next big hit. The duo was modeled after real-life hit-crafters Boyce and Hart, who pop heads might remember as the team who penned smash singles for the Monkees. All-in-all, this was one big ball of late-Sixties pop. Maybe that's why it flopped in 1971. Kids were already moving on from bubblegum to hard rock.

Image: The Everett Collection

4. The Law & Harry McGraw

Murder, She Wrote
16 episodes

Jerry Orbach was a no-filter, old-school private dick. Barbara Babcock was an attorney. Together, they were a bit of "law and order." Or course, this Murder, She Wrote spin-off completely failed, leading Orbach to join Law & Order.

Image: The Everett Collection

5. Mr. T and Tina

Welcome Back, Kotter
5 episodes

When you hear "Mr. T," you think of gold chains, a mohawk and "I pity the fool." You do not think of Mr. Miyagi. Before all that Eighties pop-culture, in 1976, Pat Morita played a widowed Japanese inventor living in America with a governess named Tina taking care of his kids. Making this all the more confusing, Morita's character was named Taro Takahashi. Around the same time, he was playing Arnold Takahaski on Happy Days, a completely different character with the same surname. Audiences were uncertain which hit sitcom was doing the spinning off.

Image: The Everett Collection

6. The New Perry Mason

Perry Mason
15 episodes

Admittedly, this is a reboot, but we had to include it. Until the 2020 HBO remake of Perry Mason with Matthew Rhys, Monte Markham was the last man to play Erle Stanley Gardner's ace defense attorney. That's him on the right. Before landing the lead in The New Perry Mason reboot, Markham had played the title role in the TV adaptation of Mr. Deeds Goes to Town — not to mention guest roles on Mary Tyler Moore and more. Perhaps the most interesting casting of this fresh 1970s attempt to revive the character was Brett Somers, best known for her one-liners on Match Game, playing Gertie, Perry's receptionist. She was rarely seen on the original, but was fleshed out more here.

Image: The Everett Collection

7. Richie Brockelman, Private Eye

The Rockford Files
5 episodes

Jim Rockford was a cool guy, driving a cool car, living in a cool spot by the beach. "Richie Brockelman" had an uphill battle convincing people he was cool. RICHIE BROCKELMAN. Strikes fear in the hearts of criminals. With that name, he sounded more like the second-chair piccolo in the high school band. His character was introduced on The Rockford Files in the episode "The House On Willis Avenue." Richie returned for another case, "Never Send a Boy King to Do a Man's Job," but his own adventures never captured an audience. Star Dennis Dugan would go on to appear in loads of Adam Sandler movies.

Image: The Everett Collection

8. The Tortellis

Cheers
13 episodes

"Not just another family comedy. Not just another family," the ads declared. Not exactly. With its uncouth, blue-collar characters, The Tortellis brought to mind the Bundys of Married… with Children. That being said, this Cheers spin-off premiered a few months before that crass Fox sitcom. The story followed Nick Tortelli, Carla's ex, to Las Vegas with his blonde trophy wife, played by Jean Kasem (wife of radio man Casey Kasem). Elvis impersonators, Charo and guest-spots from Norm (George Wendt) could not save the show. After the show flopped, the characters moved back to Boston and returned to Cheers.

Image: The Everett Collection

9. W*A*L*T*E*R

M*A*S*H
1 episode

Just looking at the title, you can tell which series this potential spinoff came from. In fact, W*A*L*T*E*R wasn't a direct spinoff of M*A*S*H, but rather born of its ill-fated spinoff AfterMASH. Radar was now going by his given name, Walter, and living in St. Louis with his cousin and a rookie cop. CBS aired the pilot episode once, and even that broadcast was preempted in some markets by the Democratic National Convention.

Image: The Everett Collection

SEE MORE: 9 successful TV shows that were spin-offs of spin-offs

It seems as if half of '70s television can trace its roots to Love, American Style. READ MORE

Save with
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Close

19 Comments

Post a comment
DavidBartholomew 19 days ago
Most of these are Back Door pilots, not spin offs. Back Door pilots are when you use an episode of a show to air a pilot, like Danny Thomas did with Andy Griffith.

A spin off is taking established characters from one show to create another. Joanie Loves Chachi is a spin off
Lillyrose 19 days ago
I never saw any of these spin-offs.
DavidBartholomew 19 days ago
Monte Markham. I remember a show from 1960s called The Second Hundred Years. He played a Alaskan miner who had been frozen and revived. He was reunited with his 50 year old son (Arthur O'Connell) and grandson (played by Markham, get the joke?).
Lola 22 days ago
I love the flintstones to this day ! I remeber every morning getting ready for school and watching this and slowing our morning down cause I was mesmerized by the show❤️They sure as heck don’t make it like this anymore and I will be 50 in June :)
Runeshaper 26 days ago
I can honestly see how some of these shows would flop. The titles on some of them weren't the best. Richie Brockelman does not strike me as a detective's name I would see on TV. I don't mean to be judgmental, but he doesn't really look like 1 either. Some of the plots seem flimsy. I love Cheers, but not so sure about The Tortellis. LOL You just can't replace Raymond Burr with someone else as Perry Mason.

On the flip side, I can't see a show with Mr. Miyagi not being popular. He was AWESOME! I would have liked to see The Law & Harry McGraw.
daDoctah Runeshaper 20 days ago
Richie Brockelman, Private Eye is *meant* to sound like an unlikely name for such a character. The same approach worked out well a bit later for Buffy the Vampire Slayer.
Utzaake 28 days ago
Remember 1, 5, 7 and 8.
5. Tina was played by Susan Blanchard who at the time was the spokeswoman for No Nonsense Pantyhose.

7. A clue to who was one of the show's creators is in the picture. That's Barbara Bosson who at the time was married to...you guessed it...Steven Bochco.
15inchBlackandWhite 28 days ago
I remember 1, 5, 8 and 9. Jean Kasem would of course get into a bizarre legal battle with her late husband's children from his prior marriage over the fate of his remains. I believe he is interred in Norway or Sweden someplace. His body kept moving one step ahead of the lawyers.
jamiahsh 29 days ago
Perhaps we meant the last time in a weekly series, but did we forget the series of Perry Mason movies of the 80s and 90s starring none other than Raymond Burr?
Amalthea 29 days ago
I remember enjoying "Blanksy's Beauties", "The Law & Harry McGraw" (even though I never watched "Murder, She Wrote), "Mr. T & Tina", and "Richie Brockelman, Private Eye". I remember "The Tortellis" only because of Jean Kasem. Also, did anyone else notice that there are only 9 shows listed?
Lillyrose Amalthea 19 days ago
I never saw "The Law & Harry McGraw,' but "Murder, She Wrote" is a great show.
RobCertSDSCascap 29 days ago
Only remember 3 of those. Just as well!
ttenchantr 29 days ago
Richie Brockelman was awful. The character was grating and annoying to the extreme.
cperrynaples ttenchantr 28 days ago
Yeah, NBC proably would have preferred a series with Tom Selleck as Lance White, but he was locked into Magnum PI! One correction you should make: Dennis Dugan didn't appear in Adam Sandler movies, he directed them!
DawnGraham 29 days ago
#4 and #7 were okay to watch. Never heard of #2,3 or 4
MrsPhilHarris 29 days ago
The only one I saw was Getting Together.
cperrynaples 29 days ago
I know all these shows, so a few comments:[a] 1 was just barely a spinoff of Happy Days! Although it featured 2 future HD regulars and Pinky Tuscadero, it existed only because ABC flopped with The Nancy Walker Show and she had a play-or-play option! [b] 5 has absolutely no connection with Kotter! However, when this show failed Pat Morita revived his Arnold character on Blansky's Beauties! [c] Without a doubt, 9 has the most awkward title of any show here! First of all, there were no purpose in using astericks since MASH was short for Mobile Army Surgical Hospital and WALTER doesn't stand for anything. Secondly, Burghoff was known on MASH as Radar, so that should have been the title!
PS For those who don't understand the first sentence of 1, I'll explain: After Blansky's Beauties, Marshall tried to relaunch the series on NBC without Nancy Walker. The result was Who's Watching The Kids, a series only really notable for launching Jim Belushi's career!
Barry22 cperrynaples 26 days ago
Pat Morita as Mr. T appeared on an episode of Kotter.
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?