Did these travelers appear on Gilligan's Island or Wagon Train?

Castaways or wagoneers?

 Warner Brothers/NBC/Universal
Gilligan's Island and Wagon Train had one thing in common: The casts of both shows had plenty of time to get to know their fellow travelers.

On one, the castaways end up on an island where occasionally other inhabitants unintentionally land. On the other, there was a constant stream of travelers joining and leaving the caravan.

Think you can tell the difference between Gilligan's wacky encounters with surfers, butterfly catchers, painters and Hollywood producers, and Wagon Train's dramatic trail of con artists, colonels and debutantes? Good luck!

Watch Gilligan's Island on MeTV!

Sundays 3 & 3:30 PM

*available in most MeTV markets
  1. Wrongway Feldman
  2. Willy Moran
  3. Duke LeMay
  4. Duke Williams
  5. Erika Tiffany-Smith
  6. Beauty Jamison
  7. Rex Montana
  8. Harold Hecuba
  9. Clara Beauchamp
  10. Norbett Wiley
  11. Beasley Waterford
  12. John Wilbot
  13. Cliff Grundy
  14. Jonathan Kincaid

Did these travelers appear on Gilligan's Island or Wagon Train?

Your Result...

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Pellentesque nec ante ipsum. Mauris viverra, urna et porta sagittis, lorem diam dapibus diam, et lacinia libero quam id risus.
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Close

108 Comments

Rambo4 1 day ago
You got 14 out of 14

You've proven you're no stranger when it comes to the best of Sixties TV.
tinkparker 2 days ago
8/14 I didn't watch wagon train that often
WILD 11 days ago
You got 14 out of 14
You've proven you're no stranger when it comes to the best of Sixties TV.

All right.
8176Morgan 12 days ago
"You got 12 out of 14. You've proven you're no stranger when it comes to the best of Sixties TV." I got tripped up on the Duke question plus I didn't remember the name Norbert Riley. I think that character was played by Don Rickles.
missbloonde 12 days ago
14/14 I watch Wagon Train a lot but I’m not as familiar with it as I am Gilligan’s Island so when I knew they weren’t on that they had to be from the other
Doug 12 days ago
13/14 In #3 I saw the name Duke and clicked too fast thinking it was the surfer in question #4
Crisco 12 days ago
9/14..saw alot of Gilligan's island but no wagon train until recently.
Jimjr5560 12 days ago
I should gotten the I missed. They actually called him Lord Beasley. Gilligan's Island is still one of my favorite shows.
George58 Jimjr5560 12 days ago
That's why I missed out on #11. If it would have read "Lord Beasley" I would have got it right.
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?