A real doctor watched M*A*S*H and pointed out what was accurate — and what wasn’t

While some scenes wouldn’t happen in real life, the classic sitcom got some surprising things right.

Read to Me

Doctor Mike Varshavski is a family medicine physician who has gained fame for his funny insights and reactions to medical movies and shows. His Youtube channel has 7.7 million subscribers and some of his videos have reached over 20 million views. Of course, the fact that People magazine named him “Sexiest Doctor Alive” might have something to do with his popularity as well.

He has watched and reacted to everything from Grey’s Anatomy to medical scenes in Seinfeld and pointed out what is and isn’t medically accurate. He recently scrutinized M*A*S*H and had plenty to say.

It goes without saying that a fictional sitcom isn’t the best source of medical information. Doctor Mike mentions a few things that would never happen in a real hospital, especially in the 21st century. But Hawkeye, Major Houlihan, Radar and the rest were working in the 1950s on the front lines of a brutal war. Certain compromises had to be made and exact protocol couldn’t always be followed.

Nevertheless, it’s a fun look at how a doctor views a medical series. One of the most accurate things M*A*S*H portrays? Doctors have notoriously bad handwriting.

Watch M*A*S*H on MeTV!

One Full Hour

Weeknights at 7 PM

*available in most MeTV markets
 
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Close

26 Comments

Post a comment
Fleiter 1 month ago
Does this guy realize the show is set in 1950?
GadgetDon 1 month ago
I'm a fan of Dr. Mike - but he was reviewing the medical treatment as if it was a clinic in 2021, not a MASH unit in the 1950s.
Pacificsun 1 month ago
I realize his channel has to be exciting, and he's got the subscribers to prove it!! But I don't think he's spent too much time in Hollywood. MASH was supposed to have Medical Consultant overseeing that stuff. But think about what they ~couldn't~ show and you get a better appreciation for what they were able to pull off!

For awhile didn't they have a limit on how much "blood" could be shown per episode?
Zip 1 month ago
Haven't watched the whole thing(would rather read a story than watch some guy's Youtube video anyway), but he seems to be using his modern day sensibilities in most of his reactions. That, and I'll bet this guy has never seen combat in a front-line unit. This type of critique would be much better coming from a doctor who was actually in a combat medical unit. And I have read some of those who have critiqued MASH.
Moverfan Zip 1 month ago
They had a doctor on the set--Dr. Walter Dishell (I think I've got his last name right) was generally the last person listed in the closing credits as their Medical Advisor.
LoveMETV22 Moverfan 1 month ago
That's a good observation. I haven't noticed that, now I'll be watching for it. Just an opinion, It's great that they had an advisor on their staff. Had the show been a medical show like say ER or Chicago Med authenticity would be more important. Yes M*A*S*H technically has a lot of surgery scenes but it's not the entire show. The video was humorous, people can critique the authenticity but it's not all that important. TY
Pacificsun Zip 1 month ago
Well said.
Andybandit 1 month ago
Great story. If that guy in the picture is the doctor. I would love to be my doctor. He is cute.
Andybandit 1 month ago
This comment has been removed.
GadgetDon Andybandit 1 month ago
Dr. Mike is a real doctor who has a YouTube channel - has a number of videos about his life at his clinic and discussing medical school and residency. He does medical reviews of various shows (Gray's Anatomy does NOT do well). Also has useful info about how to talk to your doctor about your issues, what to expect, etc.
LoveMETV22 1 month ago
Well, that was a little different style from the usual story style MeTV follows. Actually it would be nice if every so often they do a story in this format. - JMO- what do others think❓ ❓
Pacificsun LoveMETV22 1 month ago
Oh yes, always love to see the YouTubes. They could drive home a point very well with them. But my hunch is they don't want the writers to take short cuts. It's easy to get hooked on YT.
LoveMETV22 Pacificsun 1 month ago
Yes, there is lots of good video, not too bad with some free shows and movies, I had told texasluva at one time- between cable, streaming and you tube you can find practically anything.
15inchBlackandWhite 1 month ago
Years ago I saw a veteran New York City police detective on The Mike Douglas Show. He was making a similar analysis of which TV cop shows were accurate, and which were not.

His pick for the least accurate? Hawaii Five-O. Why? "Because at the end of every episode McGarrett says 'Book 'em, Danno' and if that was really the case you'd never see Danno on the show because he'd be spending all of his time in court."

His pick for the most realistic TV cop show?

Barney Miller!
Load previous comments
Pacificsun Moverfan 1 month ago
Thx for bringing back those memories!

Hey MeTV how come we don't have Barney Miller on!!

[ I know which Show it could replace! } Just sayin.... 😉
Moverfan Pacificsun 1 month ago
Barney Miller was on in the seventies--I think it went off in 1979 or 1980. Hill Street Blues was a mid-season replacement for...something in January 1981. And now that you brought it up, I have thus picture in my mind of Barney trying to deal with Mick Belker...
ValT Moverfan 1 month ago
Ahh, Moverfan, you quoted my favorite Barney Miller episode! Did you realize that Castle was also set in the twelfth precinct? I believe I read somewhere that Castle's comments about the coffee were an homage to Barney Miller.
ValT ValT 1 month ago
Sadly, Gregory Sierra has also left us. The only regular cast members still alive are Hal Linden, Barbara Barrie, and Max Gail.
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?