Pie Fight! Pick your favorite pie

Pick a pie, any pie!

 

Thanksgiving, Christmas, Fourth of July... heck, pie's even perfect for Arbor Day. 

We defy you to find a day when pie isn't the greatest. But which pie is the greatest? That's for you to decide, reader! Choose between these pies-a-plenty, and only one pie shall stand victorious! 

If you choose 'Other,' pie law mandates that you're obligated to comment with your actual choice.

  1. Which pie is your favorite?

Pie Fight! Pick your favorite pie

Your Result...

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Pellentesque nec ante ipsum. Mauris viverra, urna et porta sagittis, lorem diam dapibus diam, et lacinia libero quam id risus.
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Close

131 Comments

Moverfan 5 months ago
I want a slice of apple pie...and a slice of pumpkin pie...and one of the blueberry...and the key lime...and lemon meringue...and the peanut butter. Whipped cream on the pumpkin pie and no coconut on thr key lime at all...hate coconut with a passion. No, I think one fotk will be just fine, thank you...well, I'm all set. What's everybody else gonna have? (And how can pumpkin pie only get 70%?)
nerakr 6 months ago
Banana pudding is not a pie!
sixties1child nerakr 5 months ago
it is if you put it in a pie crust!
BradBeall 6 months ago
If you're anywhere near the Pittsburgh, PA area, you probably already know about the strawberry pie from "Eat-N-Park" restaurants. It's without question the best pie anywhere in the world!
hazy321 6 months ago
Blueberry........but actually my mom's Ricotta pineapple cheesecake. A lot of joyful hard work went into that cheesecake....a favorite holiday memory. No one even attempts to make now.
Lillyrose 6 months ago
0% similar. I picked blueberry, which is my favorite pie out of the pies listed. My favorite pie is chocolate.
bukhrn 6 months ago
I picked pumpkin, but my very favorite Is a variation of Pecan that my wife makes, Chocolate Bourbon Pecan.
Pacificsun 6 months ago
Since somebody else was making it, I picked Key Lime. A little harder to find. But when the recipe is good, very refreshing! Otherwise I like Pumpkin and Pecan because they make delicious leftovers.
Jacki 6 months ago
I like both apple and banana pudding.
LibraBaby0921 6 months ago
As much as I love good old American pie, for me it pales in comparison to blueberry, cherry, coconut cream, and peanut butter. I'll just have to set up a rotation I guess.
Artsynanna 6 months ago
hard to choose between pumpkin and apple. I picked Pumpkin.
Jeffrey 6 months ago
"70% similar" ----70% similar to the most popular responses." ----My first choice for this time of year is Pumpkin, then Cherry, Blueberry, Pecan, But Apple, Boston Creme, Rhubarb, Lemon Meringue, Key Lime & Banana Pudding, NO WAY!!
Charlotte 6 months ago
Coconut cream! I could eat a whole pie!
Beatseeker Charlotte 6 months ago
is this gilligan?
WGH 6 months ago
Apparently not many people have tried rhubarb pie. It's phenomenal.

I believe it's more of a southern thing but it is tasty
bukhrn WGH 6 months ago
Actually I believe it's more seasonal, when strawberries are fresh, Strawberry Rhubarb.
Coldnorth WGH 6 months ago
Rhubarb wine is wonderful too. I enjoy rhubarb desserts too
billygardener19 6 months ago
Nothing better than PEACH PIE (after which, Gooseberry)
Jeffrey billygardener19 6 months ago
Those two are not even on the list. Peach and GooseBerry. Yuck to both!!
Spaceseed billygardener19 6 months ago
Peach should be a cobbler with lots of sweet crust, top and bottom.
Coldnorth billygardener19 6 months ago
Never had peach pie. Sounds like it is very sweet
bre003 6 months ago
I love no sugar added Pecan Pie, getting harder to find now. And the ones that are available are to expensive to be bothered with.
Spaceseed bre003 6 months ago
Good pecans are necessary and they’re expensive.
dodgebob 6 months ago
Rhubarb
WGH dodgebob 6 months ago
I just posted that I don't think many people have tried rhubarb pie. It is the bomb.
dodgebob WGH 6 months ago
Ya, sometimes the best food doesn't sound all that tasty, but the bomb explains everything.
JeanInTN 6 months ago
I was going to say apple, but then I saw Boston cream pie on the list! It's really a cake, but it's delicious! I'm surprised the percentage is so low. If you haven't tried it, you need to! Sometimes it's called Boston cream cake now.
Jeffrey JeanInTN 6 months ago
It's the custard filling I don't like! They even use it in donuts.
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?