Natalie Schafer: Gilligan wasn't the only typecast castaway

"I cried when I got the role."

The Everett Collection

It's hard to think of an actor more associated with a character (or two) than Bob Denver. As Gilligan, Denver was globally famous for his red sweater, bucket hat, and goofy, lovable antics. He never quite shook off his time on Gilligan's Island, and the role defined the rest of his life. While having one's face adorned with all sorts of merchandise is probably nice for a while, the price couldn't have been higher for the actor. Never again would producers see Denver as anything but Gilligan.

Worse, Gilligan's Island didn't just leave its biggest star stranded. It also left its supporting cast feeling like they'd never break out of their characters, either. Being an island castaway was a great metaphor for the rest of Natalie Schafer's career, as she made it clear that she felt incredibly typecast following her time on the popular series.

In 1989, Schafer spoke with the St. Louis Post-Dispatch about how Gilligan's Island had quite a negative affect on the remainder of her professional career.

Watch Gilligan's Island on MeTV!

Sundays 3 & 3:30 PM

*available in most MeTV markets

"Most of the young executives and casting agents don't see past my role in Gilligan," said Schafer. 

"I was on stage for years before the show and I can still do drama, but they don't see it that way. I don't want to be bogged down. I didn't even want to be in Gilligan when I tested. I cried when I got the role."

So, what does a working actor do when she's so closely associated with a role she never wanted?

"I love doing voiceovers for film and commercials because you don't have to hold your stomach in," she said.

Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Close

9 Comments

deltadart 9 minutes ago
Lovey and Thurston a classic couple!

If you are going to do research on her roles; I would recommend IMdb instead of Wikipedia, its more thorough.
Badge714 12 hours ago
I still choose Mary Ann over Ginger.
Moonpie 1 day ago
She was also in an episode of Thriller (METV please add it to your schedule) with William Shatner which was really good.
Snickers 2 days ago
So if you didn't want the role why test for it? Just does not make sense to me. And if you got the part you could always have said no thank you Natalie
JHP 2 days ago
the whole cast became type cast - gees
CoreyC 2 days ago
The truth is that no one would have heard of Natalie Schafer if it wasn't for Gilligan's Island.
Mempatfan CoreyC 2 days ago
Years later, she guest starred on Vega$ with Robert Urich in a similar role.
Robersot Mempatfan 2 days ago
One appearance on I Love Lucy,another on The Brady Bunch. That's all I've ever seen of her
Hollie CoreyC 1 day ago
the truth is , maybe try some research, start with Wikipedia you'll find list and list of shows and performance,, that's the trouble with this country , never look back further than your age ,,maga has a deep problem with this issue
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?